Skip to main content

THE FEAR OF PARTICULARITY ON THE LEFT


John Clarke
July 24, 2018


Some time ago, an especially dogmatic and thus ultimately unendurable Facebook friend, made a testy response to something I put up on the refugee crisis. This person denounced me for even speaking of a 'refugee crisis'. The person believed that it was because it was, they asserted, really a crisis of capitalism. That struck me as rather like condemning someone for saying they were eating an orange on the grounds that what they were actually eating was fruit.

What I unfortunately see all the time among dogmatic and narrow thinkers on the left, is a stubborn refusal to consider engaging in discussion of incredibly important particular issues and developments out of a fear that this might contaminate previously established general concepts. By doing this, however, those fundamentally correct concepts are reduced to mere lifeless abstractions. Thus, rather than test previously established conclusions against a developing reality, that reality must be made to conform to a previously determined letter of the law. The lengths that some will go to in this regard are quite remarkable.

I recently put up another post on Facebook, something about impoverished disabled people in Bolivia demanding a bare pension and facing police brutality in the process. Someone, not the same person as above, replied that these people were dupes of the American State Department and even questioned if they were really disabled. You encounter a blanket view, in fact, that popular struggles in oppressed countries can only serve imperialism.

Social democracy is not a revolutionary force and socialism will not come from a vote in some Parliament, but to suggest that Jeremy Corbyn is no different to Tony Blair and the rejuvenation of the Labour Party is only a distraction is absurd. Without relating to and intervening in such developments, we are reduced to forming a small band of like minded people and preparing for the Revolution in the way you wait of the number nine bus to show up.

Liberals constantly present Trump as an inexplicable evil who came out of nowhere. He emerged from what came before, of course, but to suggest that the present ascendency of the most ruthless and reckless elements in the USA ruling class is of no consequence is disorientated. At times I've even been challenged when I have suggested that the Israeli leadership is discarding pretensions of liberal democracy and a 'peace process' and working to complete the colonial project, on the grounds that I am sowing illusions in liberal Zionism.

The general concepts about capitalism and its global order that we have developed are of enormous importance but they have validity only to the extent that they are applied. They ossify if they are misused as a way of blocking consideration of particularity and a
meaningful intervention in the complex and rapidly developing reality of the capitalist crisis and class struggle.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HOW THE COVID PANDEMIC HAS CHANGED PANHANDLING by Jim Ward

Panhandling, i.e., begging for small change on the street, has been under considerable threat since the coming of Covid. Of course, the practice has been under threat before whenever the good burgers of some city find that the poor have resorted to “inconveniencing” the public and they feel the “moral” need to criminalize it. But Covid is causing different constraints. In these times very few people carry cash with them. In fact, many retailers will not accept cash, since it may well be ‘dirty money’. The term panhandling had its origins, so I’m told, during an economic depression in the United States in the late 19th century. That depression hit the panhandle area of northern Texas particularly hard and it caused many workers to head to New York City, where the ‘Buddy can you spare a dime?’ request was given birth. The practitioners of this art became known as the panhandlers. Back in the early 1970s I conducted studies of panhandling approaches in six North American cities, one of th...
Post a Comment
Read more

THE TRAGEDY OF HAMLET: THE FATAL ERROR OF INDIVIDUALISM by Bill Lee

  I suspect I am not alone in remembering that I was taught in high school English class that Shakespeare’s great tragedy, Hamlet, was about a man who simply could not make up his mind to take action and get vengeance for the murder of his father. The lesson that Shakespeare was laying down for us, we were told, was that Hamlet dithered, was indecisive, and that his failure to act decisively led to his own downfall and the death of others. But that was, and is, a superficial reading of the play. I had the opportunity while at university in Houston, of studying under, and knowing, a very perceptive English professor and my mentor, who helped his students understand the real tragedy. It is one that has never left me and a teaching that I urge all of us to think about. What we learned in that English class was that the real tragedy of Hamlet was more social and political than personal. It was not simply that he was indecisive but that, more importantly, he refused to acknowledge and u...
Post a Comment
Read more

Bleak Times for Trump’s USA? by Bill Lee

“If we don’t put a stake into the heart of this administration, there  may not be an election in 2028.” Gavin Newsom, Governor of California The news from the US of A about the wild and weird pronouncements and actions of the abhorrent individual sitting in the most powerful seat in the land, DJ Trump, is bleak. There is his destructive mania for imposing tariffs on every nation in the world: his corrupt attempt to block public knowledge of the truth of the sordid matter of the Epstein files; his racist hatred of Brown and Black people and his inhumane policy of arresting them willy nilly and illegally deporting many; his war on the hard won rights of women and other minorities; his ignoring of court orders (he owns a more or less corrupt Supreme Court); his impossible and unhinged comments on wanting Canada to become the 51st state of the USA; and his increasingly wacky and garbled speech, are only the most recent concerns. But probably the most dangerous of his right-wing campaig...
Post a Comment
Read more