Skip to main content

THE INESCAPABLE REALITY OF THE CANADIAN GENOCIDE by Bill Lee



We have made it past Canada Day with the existential angst about the calls for and against the cancelation of celebrations. Whatever people did, or didn’t do, to acknowledge the competing desires for the “holiday” however, we need to come to grips with the meaning of the term genocide. I keep stumbling over posts, or letters to editors, complaining of its use because there was no huge slaughter of Indigenous people (though we don’t really know yet the total numbers of the lives lost to neglect and abuse in residential “schools”. And we often fail to take into account the numbers who died thanks to the hunger/starvation due to John A. MacDonald’s policy of “clearing the plains”). Because of the way we have been taught our history, up until recently, we tend to believe that genocide must involve the outright killing of a people; like the herding of six million European Jews, as well as Gays and Roma, into gas chambers in Nazi Germany; or the murder of 1.5 million Armenians by the Turkish state in 1915; or the re-“education” death camps in Laos by Pol Pot where 1.5 to 2 million people, from 1975 to 1979, nearly a quarter of Cambodia's 1975 population, met their deaths; the Bosnian Serb forces initiated a program of “ethnic cleansing resulting in the deaths of some 100,000 Bozniaks or Bosnian Muslims (with the backing of the Serb-dominated Yugoslav army). Hitory.com Editors. (2019). But genocide can look very different under different circumstances.

We need to really come to grips with the fact that genocide can involve cultural as well as physical extermination. It doesn’t matter whether the aim is to “kill the Indian in the child” or more directly, to ‘kill the Indian”. This is understood, in the UN Genocide Prevention declaration, to be a strategy of genocide. The Canadian residential school system of the forced assimilation of thousands of Indigenous children (where they lost language, community and their families) that was aimed at ridding Canada of Indigenous culture was, de-facto, an effort to purge Canada of Indigenous people. Of course, the practitioners of the strategy, the men who conceived, funded, monitored and regulated the policy, like Prime Minister John A. MacDonald
and the loathsome Duncan Campbell Scott, didn’t blink an eye at the evidence that many people, including children, would perish as a result of their policies and actions. And we know that people did die, in the thousands. So, the Canadian actions are more than covered by the definition.

Also, we cannot try to take refuge in the notion that the evil of systemic colonial oppression is behind us. In the 1930’s we now know of the cruel experiments about malnutrition that were undertaken on residential school students. Not surprisingly, there were deaths. And it was only in the 1940’s that the vile practice of the philosophy of eugenics - the sterilization of Indigenous women - was discontinued. We are aware, or should be, of the “60’s scoop” replacing residential schools in the effort of assimilation. Similarly, there has been more than sufficient media coverage of the deliberate systemic underfunding of on reserve Indigenous health services, education, water safety, housing, etc. Further, as of January 2021, only 10 of the 94 Calls to Action of The Truth and reconciliation Commission, made in 2015, had been completely implemented. So, we have by no means extricated ourselves from the fetid sewer of colonialism. Any talk of reconciliation is meaningless until we have done that.

But to return to the subject of facing up to our history, it is frustrating and saddening to see some individuals popping up on fb to deny Canadian genocidal intentions and practices. It is a ludicrous denial of historical facts and contemporary reality. But worse, it is needlessly insensitive and downright hurtful to our Indigenous brothers and sisters.

We are facing what has been years, decades of silence and denial. A country, like an individual, reaps what it sows, and ours has sown colonial brutality and lies about it. Canadian Colonialism apparently has an expensive side.

My Globe and Mail the other morning had the headline that it may take as much as a billion dollars to find all the residential school graves. Looks like our country is no longer going to be able to live off the avails of colonial crimes, we’re actually going to have to start paying for them. We are seeing that now and we have to deal honestly with it.

Resources:

For those who may feel uninformed, and to be fair, until recently, our education system was abysmally, even criminally inadequate, below I am providing a few resources, some of which have been referred to in the article, from a plethora of sources, that I hope people will read and from which they can benefit.
Bosnian Genocide. https://www.history.com/topics/1990s/bosnian-genocide

Canada’s shameful history of nutrition research on residential school children: The need for strong medical ethics in Aboriginal health research. Paediatrics Child Health. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3941673/

Clearing the Plains: Disease, Politics of Starvation and the Loss of Indigenous Life. James Daschuk (2014). University of Regina Press
The Charge of Genocide. https://www.facinghistory.org/stolen-lives-indigenous-peoples-canada-and-indian-residential-schools/historical-background/charge-genocide

Cultural Genocide in Canada? It Did Happen Here. https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/aps/index.php/aps/article/download/28804/pdf/77632
DEFINITIONS. Genocide. https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml.

Discovery of Indigenous children's remains evidence of Canada's genocide: experts. https://www.cp24.com/news/discovery-of-indigenous-children-s-remains-evidence-of-canada-s-genocide-experts-1.5451613?cache=%3FclipId%3D104066
FORCED STERILIZATION OF INDIGENOUS WOMEN IN CANADA. https://ijrcenter.org/forced-sterilization-of-indigenous-women-in-canada/

The Genocide Question and Indian Residential Schools in Canada. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/256047027_The_Genocide_Question_and_Indian_Residential_Schools_in_Canada

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ANY LEFT LEFT? OR WHY I AM DISAPPOINTED IN THE NDP

 By Bil Lee Prior to announcing that they would not support the Liberal budget (thus triggering an election over what was really a pretty left friendly Liberal program) the NDP in Ontario has been wasting a great deal of breath on hammering the Liberals over the "gas plant" scandal. Of course the Libs have been their old tricky and disingenuous selves in many ways and did waste a pile of money (and try to cover up how much) attempting to score some bi-election wins by cancelling the damn things. But the fact is the PC's and the NDP had both made a promise to cancel them if they got into power, so the money ws going to be wasted in any event. So it was all game playing, and pretty boring game playing actually. I am not against a solid critique of the Libs (except I continue to disagree on the utility of playing at the gas thing). My concern with role back of corporate tax breaks that Horvath has muted about as an election promise is that though I clearly support the ide...
4 comments
Read more

RITUALS KEEP CHANGING by Tony Boonstra

It is interesting that since time immemorial people have developed rituals. Sometimes we forget the initial meaning of the ritual. Take Christmas. It was originally “the Mass being celebrated at the time of Christ's birth”. That is literally what the word means. What I found helpful is an idea I came across in my studies at McGill University years ago. One professor shared with us the difference between a sign and a symbol. A sign is literally what it says. So, when one comes to a stop sign there is only one meaning. Stop. No rolling stops allowed. The meaning of a symbol on the other hand, is the meaning that a community embraces. This can change over time as the community's values and belief systems undergo changes. In the Netherlands they celebrate Sinter Klaas-Santa Claus, on December 5. The celebration takes on much of the meaning of what Christmas is in Canada. There is goodwill, exchanges of gifts, celebrations, etc. Then Christmas is a quiet day for reflection and for C...
1 comment
Read more

WHY DOES NATIONALISM CONTINUE TO TRUMP CLASS?

By: Jim Ward   In his less insightful moments, when he attempted to predict the future (a mugs game at any stage of history), Karl Marx predicted that eventually the awareness of class would trump that of nationalism.  He was, of course, terribly wrong in that prediction.  World War 1, known in its time as The Great War, blinded lots of good British, French, Canadian, German, American, Australian and Turkish working-class lads to the fact that their lives were much the same, selling their labour on the cheap to the benefit of the few that geared them up for war.  Women too, although not major participants in the shooting war, did their bit to ensure their male counterparts were willing to pay the ‘ultimate sacrifice’ for their god and their country.  Young women in London where ever-ready to present young men not in the shooting war with white feathers, branding them cowards , unwilling to fight for “their freedoms ”  Those Bri...
1 comment
Read more