Skip to main content

THE STATE OF OUR “CARING”: Residential School Graves and The Public Interest by Bill Lee

 For Canada, the issue of the residential school horror is part of one of the two equally important/vital/fundamental issues facing this country. The one, is the existential crisis of climate change of course. The other, of which the issue of the unmarked graves of innocent children forms an important part, is ending Canada’s colonial relationship with Indigenous people. This is issue is being foregrounded1 and has been in the news for some months.


There is increasing concern, even fear, among a good deal of the caring public that the issue of the many unmarked graves of residential school students is falling out of the attention of the general public. The fear is that what occurred to those interred, thyoung victims of Canadian colonialism, is that it is in danger of going under the rug. The first is dismaying but to a certain extent understandable. Our contemporary society has a notoriously short attention span, the news cycle is a short one, and there is an array of genuinely important issues facing us, the climate crisis, recovery from the pandemic, affordable housing are only a few. But I'm troubled by a second concern. It is that I believe that we are seeing unscrupulous individuals attempting to deny its scope and/or its profound seriousness. For example, I see any number of letters to the editor and Facebook posts suggesting that while there “might have been” bad things perpetrated by “bad apples” (like the ones that we hear about in the police forces perhaps?) the intentions were always good, both on the part of the government as well as on the various gangs who actually administered and staffed these houses of horror. One fellow insisted on quoting Thompson Highway, the noted Cree author and playwright that he had a positive experience and “learned to play the piano”. While this is pure baloney and bolox, we know that a lie big enough and said sufficiently often can inflict significant damage2. We need look no further than the crazy and violent goings on south of the border, fired by the mendacity of Trump and the wild conspiracies of the QAnon movement. Conservative leader, O’Toole, has called for an end to flying our Canadian flag at Half Mast which has been in place in recognition of the continuing (not a few one offs) discoveries of the unmarked graves on old residential school sites. He says he is concerned that to a flag at half mast makes it impossible to have pride in our country. My view, on the other, is that we can actually be proud that we are finally facing up to this colonial outrage. Our pride in this country must never be tied to a false historical narrative. The growth and pride will, must, depend on the degree to which we make our country one of honesty, compassion and justice. These three things appear to be values that O’Toole and his Conservative gang3 have nether interest or commitment.

Let’s be clear on this, once and for all. There can be no more bull excrement and stupid mendacity about good intentions, or “there were some good places”, or there were some good teachers”, or using a quote from some guy, like Thompson Highway (fine playwright though he may be) who says he had a good experience. To the extent that they exist, they are rare exceptions to the rule of the overwhelming factual evidence, RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS were G-E-N-O-C-I-D-E in conception, intent and implementation. If we can face up to this as part of our unhappy colonial history, and the contemporary colonial to which it heir, and make the genuine apologies and reparations that are required, we will be on a road to be proud of indeed.

But we have to keep up the work. And until it is complete, until we have a good reason for raising it, let us keep our flag at half mast.

Resources:
Lee B. (Compiled) (2021) “215: Nine Indigenous Voices”. Critical Perspectives and Reflections. June 21.
Walsh, M. Kirku, K., Stone, L. (20211). “Flags on federal buildings, at half-mast since spring, should be raised: O’Toole”. The Gloobe and Mail. HTTPS://WWW.THEGLOBEANDMAIL.COM/POLITICS/ARTICLE-FLAGS-ON-FEDERAL-BUILDINGS-AT-HALF-MAST-SINCE-SPRING-SHOULD-BE-RAISED/. AUG. 26

1 See for example Lee (2021). “Nine Indigenous Voices” 2 As well of course, these lies about the evil of the residential schools bring great needless sorrow and frustration and trigger trauma reactions on the part of survivors and their relatives. 3 Let us keep in mind that it is only recently that we have seen the end of the public career of that vile residential school denier, former Conservative Senator Lyn Beyak. Her party appears to have a particularly difficult time facing up to the genocidal nature of the residential school “project”.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ANY LEFT LEFT? OR WHY I AM DISAPPOINTED IN THE NDP

 By Bil Lee Prior to announcing that they would not support the Liberal budget (thus triggering an election over what was really a pretty left friendly Liberal program) the NDP in Ontario has been wasting a great deal of breath on hammering the Liberals over the "gas plant" scandal. Of course the Libs have been their old tricky and disingenuous selves in many ways and did waste a pile of money (and try to cover up how much) attempting to score some bi-election wins by cancelling the damn things. But the fact is the PC's and the NDP had both made a promise to cancel them if they got into power, so the money ws going to be wasted in any event. So it was all game playing, and pretty boring game playing actually. I am not against a solid critique of the Libs (except I continue to disagree on the utility of playing at the gas thing). My concern with role back of corporate tax breaks that Horvath has muted about as an election promise is that though I clearly support the ide...
4 comments
Read more

RITUALS KEEP CHANGING by Tony Boonstra

It is interesting that since time immemorial people have developed rituals. Sometimes we forget the initial meaning of the ritual. Take Christmas. It was originally “the Mass being celebrated at the time of Christ's birth”. That is literally what the word means. What I found helpful is an idea I came across in my studies at McGill University years ago. One professor shared with us the difference between a sign and a symbol. A sign is literally what it says. So, when one comes to a stop sign there is only one meaning. Stop. No rolling stops allowed. The meaning of a symbol on the other hand, is the meaning that a community embraces. This can change over time as the community's values and belief systems undergo changes. In the Netherlands they celebrate Sinter Klaas-Santa Claus, on December 5. The celebration takes on much of the meaning of what Christmas is in Canada. There is goodwill, exchanges of gifts, celebrations, etc. Then Christmas is a quiet day for reflection and for C...
1 comment
Read more

Lifeboats for the rich will sink us all – Income Inequality and Climate Change

 By: Mike Balkwill Climate change are words that form a constant hum in the background of my thoughts. It is an anxious hum and is the result of a lot of gathering a lot of information about climate change, its causes, its current and anticipated impacts on the ecosystem and therefore on human society. The hum goes like this – “Everything is going to change, everything has to change. Will the people I love survive?” In order for humanity, (and many other species) to survive the effects of the changing climate people who live in societies with capitalist economies are going to have to change everything about how we live.  One source I have read says that in the industrialized economies that means reducing everything we do that uses fossil fuels by 90%. This means anything that we do ten times in a day, or ten times in a week, or ten times in a month that requires fossil fuels we would now be able to do only once a day, one time in a week, or just once in a month. If I...
1 comment
Read more